Phantom Blade Zero Reviews Are Out: 88 on Metacritic, 91 on OpenCritic and One 6/10. I'd Buy It on PS5, but PC Players Should Read the Stutter Reports First

Some games you root for before you've played a minute of them. Phantom Blade Zero is one of those for me: a Chinese studio that spent years on mobile games, a martial-arts world built around real Chinese weapons, and a run of trailers that made people ask whether the combat could really be that good. Today the review embargo lifted, and we finally get to hear from the people who have played it.

The short version is warm. Metacritic shows an 88 on both PC and PS5, and OpenCritic's top-critic average is 91 with every counted critic recommending it, according to reports from EGW.news and Notebookcheck. The review counts were still climbing when those outlets wrote, so treat every number here as a snapshot from Oct. 26. I haven't played the game. Everything below is read from published reviews and the reports linked at the bottom, plus my own sorting of them.

The score wall: who gave what

EGW.news listed scores from 23 outlets. I counted them myself and drew the ladder below, with the biggest group as the full bar. The roundup lists VGC at 8/10, which matches the 4/5 Notebookcheck reports.

Counted from EGW.news's list on Oct. 26. TheSixthAxis, which Notebookcheck lists at 9/10, isn't in that roundup, so I left it out of my count.

Do the arithmetic and the plain average of those 23 scores comes out around 9.0 out of 10. Metacritic shows 88. I wouldn't read that as a mismatch. Metacritic uses its own pool of outlets and its own weighting, and I'm not claiming to reproduce its formula. What I like about the ladder is the shape: 18 of 23 outlets at 9 or higher, four at 8, and exactly one at 6.

A wall of nines with one real dissent isn't a mixed reception. It's a strong one with a voice worth reading, and that voice is where I'm going next.

What critics agree on, and where they split

I went through the review excerpts in the EGW.news roundup and Notebookcheck's summary and sorted the praise and the pushback into three piles.

Here's what I notice. Almost none of the complaints touch the thing you'd buy the game for. A person shopping for fast sword combat and a person shopping for a great plot are reading two different review pages. Eurogamer's 6 is the only low mark where the complaint reaches the fighting itself, through balance, and that's the review I'd read in full before spending $59.99. The score is the headline. The reasons are the useful part.

The PC question: six performance reports side by side

Notebookcheck rounded up what reviewers said about performance. I put those reports into cards so you can compare them without squinting. These are individual reviewers' machines and settings, not benchmarks I ran.

Look at the two PC cards. Same engine, same week, opposite feelings. One outlet saw a smooth 100 fps and the other saw 60 fps that felt bad. Those two facts can both be true, because average frame rate and frame pacing are different things. A game can post a healthy fps number and still feel uneven if frames arrive unevenly.

I can't tell you which experience will be more common, and I'd be suspicious of anyone who claims they can from a handful of reviews. My guess, and it is only a guess, is that drivers, CPUs and settings matter as much as the graphics card. Notebookcheck also says S-GAME reportedly released a patch for several technical problems, though how well it works wasn't verified. On PS5 the reports look steadier, with the Creative Bloq slowdowns as the exception.

Can your PC run it? Specs and the 145 GB catch

These are the system requirements S-GAME published when pre-orders opened, as laid out by Prima Games. Both targets assume upscaling, so playing at native resolution will be heavier.

Now the part that surprised me. The GPU isn't the catch. The drive is. GameWatcher reports S-GAME's figure of about 145 GB for the PC install, with 300 GB of free space recommended for pre-loading, because the extra room is needed during the process. The PS5 pre-install is about 134.9 GB, per Twisted Voxel.

One more PC detail: DSOGaming reports the game uses Denuvo anti-tamper. I mention it only because some players care, and I'm not drawing any conclusion from it.

Price, editions and the launch clock

Pricing comes from the PlayStation announcement as reported by RPG Site, and Prima Games lays out what each edition holds.

The Deluxe Edition adds the Wulin Legend and Blood-Steel Form outfits plus a digital artbook and soundtrack. The pre-order bonus, the Treasure Basin accessory and the Legacy outfit, can also be earned in the game, and Prima says the accessory raises the Remnant Dust drop rate by 10%. Outlets disagree on whether the two Deluxe outfits can also be earned in the game, so check the store page before paying the extra $10.

Two more facts from the reporting. Prima says Phantom Blade Zero isn't coming to any PlayStation Plus tier. And Twisted Voxel reports a retailer, Play-Asia, said there will be no physical PS5 edition, which I'd treat as reported rather than confirmed.

Now the clock. The date is Oct. 29, but the unlock time depends on where you live, per Vice.

1. Oct. 26 · 7 PM Pacific · 10 PM EasternPS5 pre-load starts for pre-orders, per Twisted Voxel. I didn't find a stated pre-load start for PC.
2. Oct. 28 · 7 PM Pacific · 10 PM Eastern · 11 PM BrasíliaThe game unlocks. This is why Steam shows Oct. 28.
3. Oct. 29 · 2 AM GMT · 3 AM GermanyThe same moment for the UK and most of Europe.

Who should buy now: six kinds of players

This is my own sorting from the reviews and the specs. I haven't played the game, so read each call as a starting point.

My five-minute checklist before launch night

Run these four before you click buy. It takes less time than the download.

1. Pick your platform honestly.The PS5 reports are steadier today. If you own both a PS5 and a good PC, I'd lean console for a first playthrough.
2. Check your space.About 145 GB on PC or about 134.9 GB on PS5, with the pre-load room on top. An SSD isn't optional on PC.
3. Choose the edition.The $10 gap buys outfits and digital extras. Confirm on the store page whether the Deluxe outfits can be earned anyway.
4. Find your launch minute.Oct. 28 at 7 PM Pacific is when it unlocks, which is Oct. 29 in Europe and most of Asia.

My take

Here's where I land, and it's less about the number than the shape. A wall of nines, a few eights and a single six tells me Phantom Blade Zero has a very strong center and some rough edges. If the center is what you came for, that's a good deal. And the center, in nearly every review, is combat that moves like a martial-arts film. IGN's reviewer says it didn't wear out over about 50 hours, and that is the kind of line that makes me want to try it myself.

I also find the backstory hard not to root for. KrASIA's profile says S-GAME spent roughly seven years making mobile games before returning to single-player, and Press Start notes the game is a spiritual rebirth of a 2010 RPG Maker project called Rainblood: Town of Death. S-GAME has also said the weapons were referenced from traditional Chinese weaponry, with some made by artisans, and that more than 20 martial artists worked on motion capture, including sword masters from Mount Emei. A studio that took that road and landed critics calling it one of the year's best is the kind of story I like writing about. It's why the cover is a real Chinese sword from a museum instead of a game screenshot.

Now the practical part. On PS5, I'd buy it at launch if fast sword fighting is your thing, because those reports are the steadiest. On PC, I'd do the boring, smart thing: check your hardware against the list, clear the drive, and read a few player reports from launch day before deciding. Not because I think it's bad, but because the two PC reviews I found disagree so sharply. And if story matters most to you, read Push Square and IGN first. Both gave it a 9, and both say the plot plays it safe.

One last thought. Scores like these tempt us to turn a game into a verdict. I'd rather treat the 88 as an invitation. Fifty hours of combat that stays fresh is a promise only your own hands can confirm.

Quick answers